Metal Siding vs. Vinyl: What’s the Better Option?

If you’re considering changing the exterior of your home, it’s not always the easiest decision to make. Many homeowners in Michigan comparing metal siding vs. vinyl siding understand both options are popular. However, they do differ and perform very differently when it comes to durability, maintenance, and long-term value. If you’re wondering which option best suits your needs, keep reading to explore more about how these two choices compare.

What Are Metal and Vinyl Siding Made Of?

Metal Siding 

Metal siding is typically composed of either steel or aluminum. Hallmark features of steel are durability, strength, and fire resistance. Color options have expanded a lot over the years thanks to durable baked-on finishes, giving homeowners more freedom than ever. Metal siding is also customizable, such as siding that looks like wood.

Vinyl siding

Vinyl siding is made of PVC plastic. It’s another popular choice across the country because of the different color choices and affordability. Many homeowners choose vinyl because it can mimic the look of wood without the heavy upkeep. That’s important for busy families on the go who don’t have time to prioritize maintenance.

Durability and Maintenance: How Do They Compare?

A primary consideration for metal siding vs. vinyl siding is how easy they are to maintain.  Metal siding is tough. It stands up extremely well to:

• Hail and high winds
• Fire hazards
• Moisture and rot

It also doesn’t warp or crack over time. Maintenance is minimal, usually limited to an occasional rinse with a garden hose. The ease of maintenance is one of the primary reasons why it has become so popular across more homes in Michigan.

Vinyl siding offers decent durability for the cost, and it won’t rust or require repainting. However, it’s more prone to:

• Cracking in freezing temperatures
• Melting or warping near heat sources (like grills or reflected sunlight)
• Fading over time in direct UV exposure

Maintenance is still simple, but vinyl tends to show wear earlier than metal. It could be a great fit if you are working within a tighter budget.

Weather Resistance: A Major Factor for Michigan Homes

Whether you’re a native resident or moved to Michigan recently, you realize there are extreme temperatures here that can wreak havoc on your home. From winter ice to summer heat, your home’s exterior can take a beating. Metal siding handles extreme temperature swings well and doesn’t become brittle in cold weather. It’s also highly resistant to moisture, which is an advantage in areas with a lot of precipitation.

Vinyl siding is good for milder climates. While it can handle Michigan weather, it’s more likely to crack during deep freezes.

If you’re updating a home in a region with fluctuating temperatures (like Mid Michigan), metal often holds up better over time.

Metal Siding Vs. Vinyl Siding Cost Comparison

When you’re making a home upgrade, the investment you’ll make matters. It’s important to understand how long your siding choice will last and what to expect with installation costs. Vinyl siding is typically cheaper to buy and install. It’s a great option for homeowners on a tight budget.
Metal siding has a higher upfront cost, but you gain major durability in return. The longevity of a metal roof can’t be denied, often lasting upwards of 50 years or more. If you care for vinyl siding, it can still last 20 to 40 years, but it will likely require more repair and potential panel replacements along the way. Ultimately, the higher initial cost of metal siding is often offset by its low long-term maintenance and exceptional lifespan.

Energy Efficiency Differences

Both materials offer potential for improved energy efficiency. This depends on the insulation installed beneath them. Metal siding can be coated with reflective finishes to help redirect heat, while vinyl siding benefits from foam insulation backing. The quality of the underlying insulation is the most significant factor in maximizing your home’s energy savings with either choice.

Which Michigan Homes Benefit From Each Option? 

If you’re still on the fence about which siding option is best for your home, consider the summary of the advantages below. 

Metal Siding can be a good pick for

• Homes in areas with severe weather
• Modern or farmhouse-style homes
• Homeowners wanting maximum durability
• Anyone planning to stay in their house for decades

Vinyl Siding Works best for:

• Budget-conscious homeowners
• Mild-weather regions
• Rental properties or shorter-term ownership
• Traditional residential neighborhoods

Enhance Your Home’s Exterior With Mid-Michigan Metal Sales

At Mid-Michigan Metal Sales, we are proud to provide top of the line products for metal siding, metal roofing, shingles, and more. Don’t hesitate to contact us or shop online today.  We look forward to serving homeowners throughout the central Michigan area.